Ignore the runtime number on the box
Published runtime figures in this category are close to meaningless, and we can prove it with three examples from our own research.
The Greenworks 60V 21 inch has three different official figures. Amazon says up to 60 minutes. The box says up to 45. The Greenworks website says 45 in one place and 50 in another. An owner called Greenworks six times, got two agents who contradicted each other, then measured it himself in best case conditions and got just under 45 minutes.
Sun Joe goes the other way. Amazon lists 25 minutes for the 24V-X2-17LM. Owners repeatedly time 45 to 60 minutes, and two of them used a stopwatch.
SKIL lists the PM4910-15 cutting width as 3 inches in Amazon structured spec block. The mower cuts 20 inches.
Nobody states the conditions behind their runtime claim, which makes the numbers impossible to compare between brands. Use yard size ratings and owner reports instead, and that is why every review on this site carries the source of its spec data.
What kills the battery on a lawn mower
Four things, in order of how much they cost you.
Heat. One Greenworks owner ran the same mower across two seasons and isolated temperature as the variable. At 90F he got 15 to 20 minutes. At 65 to 70F he got about 45 minutes from the same mower on the same lawn. Ambient temperature alone swung his runtime by two to three times. Mow in the morning or the evening and you will get noticeably more done per charge.
A dull blade. A Greenworks 80V owner found his mower started chewing up batteries after a year. Sharpening the blade fixed it. A blunt blade makes the motor work harder for longer, so treat an uneven cut as your prompt to sharpen rather than a sign the mower is worn out.
Self-propel. Owners across EGO and Greenworks consistently report runtime dropping sharply with the drive engaged. Several bought push models specifically for that reason, and more than one says the mower is light enough that the drive is never missed on flat ground.
Wet or long grass. Reported on every single mower in our top ten without exception. One owner raised his deck a notch and finished his whole yard where he previously could not, which is the cheapest fix available.
Compare battery warranties before you compare runtime
The battery is the part that fails and the part that costs most to replace, so warranty length tells you more than any headline figure.
- EGO: 5 year tool, 3 year battery. One owner had a battery that would not charge past four bars out of the box, replaced free inside a week with no return required.
- Greenworks: 3 to 4 years on tool and battery depending on platform. A 5.0Ah 60V replacement runs about $174.00.
- Sun Joe: 2 years covering both batteries, extendable up to 3 more years on registration.
- LawnMaster: 1 year on the battery. One owner saw runtime fall to about 5 minutes after two seasons and only 15 to 20 uses, and bought a Greenworks instead for its longer coverage. Replacement LawnMaster batteries are $49.99 each, which does soften the blow.
- SKIL: replacement 6.0Ah batteries run about $174.38 and 2.5Ah about $109.00.
Match the deck width to your lawn, not your ambition
A 21 inch deck means fewer passes and a faster mow, which is why every mower in our top four cuts 21 inches. A 21 inch deck also draws more power per pass, weighs more and costs more.
Under about 5,000 sq ft, a 17 inch mower like the Sun Joe or the lighter LawnMaster will finish the job and be easier to store and handle. Between 5,000 sq ft and a quarter acre, 20 to 21 inches earns its keep. Above a quarter acre, plan on two batteries whatever you buy.
Push or self-propelled
Slopes are the deciding factor, not lawn size. Cordless mowers weigh 36 to 82 lbs and roll easily on flat ground, and owners of push models repeatedly say they do not miss the drive. One EGO owner considered the self-propelled version, read about the effect on battery life, picked the push model for his half acre, and now questions whether anyone needs the drive.
On slopes the drive is worth the money and the lost runtime. Two things to know if you buy one. Turn the speed dial down before your first mow, because the top setting is quicker than you expect. And release the drive before you turn.
Check whether the battery and charger are included
Every mower in our top ten ships with at least one battery and a charger, which is not true across the wider category. Tool-only listings look like bargains until you price a battery, and a 6.0Ah pack can cost more than half the mower.
Buying into a platform you already own tools for is the other saving worth chasing. EGO 56V, Greenworks 24V and 60V, WORX PowerShare and SKIL PWR CORE 40 batteries all cross over to trimmers, blowers and saws on the same system.